The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation

Dr Shock
June 4, 2009

tms12

The field of placebo response with the use of devices as treatment for major depression is hardly researched. Herb one of my very much appreciated readers and commenter asked me about the evidence on the placebo response to devices for major depression, didn’t have an answer. Tried searching but to no effect until recent. A lot of devices such as treatment with Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS), Vagus Nerve Stimulation (VNS) and transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) are under study for the treatment of depression, mostly treatment resistant depression.

Two recent meta-analyzes showed that placebo effect plays a significant role in clinical trials of major depressive disorder (MDD). The mean responder raters in the placebo group in antidepressant trials are 29.7% and the drug-placebo differences might be relatively small in patients with MDD due to the large placebo response.

rTMS studies are not optimal to say the least. The allocation to treatment arm is sometimes not mentioned,most of the randomized controlled trials are only single blind and a minority address the integrity of blinding, some of the trials only use completer analyses instead of intention to treat analyzes. For a recent update on the opinion of Dr Shock on rTMS for depression read a recent post on this blog: Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Gains approval of the FDA for Depression.

In a recent meta analysis in PLoS Medicine they assessed the placebo response of escitalopram and perform an exploratory comparison with rTMS a non-pharmacological intervention trough a systematic review and meta-analysis of recent clinical trials of major depression.

The authors concluded:

We confirmed that placebo response in MDD is large regardless of the intervention and is associated with depression refractoriness and treatment combination (add-on rTMS studies). The magnitude of the placebo response seems to be related with study population and study design rather than the intervention itself.

Patients with severe depression and with treatment-resistant depression present a lower placebo response; while in trials that rTMS is as augmentation of an antidepressant drug, the placebo response is larger. More important the placebo-drug response appears to be larger than sham-rTMS response. This finding is contrary to conventional wisdom that sham devices would have a higher placebo response than placebo pills.

Drawback of this analysis is the difference in study population. In rTMS trials mostly treatment resistant depressed patients were included in contrast to the medication trial, the duration of the trials is shorter for rTMS trials, blinding in rTMS trials is mostly single blind, the rater doesn’t know the treatment condition. The authors used several statistic techniques to eliminate the influence of heterogeneity.


Why is this important?

I have always found it strange that such a new treatment should be tryed first on difficult to treat medication resistant depressed patients. The authors agree with me, in their meta-analyzes refractoriness is associated with a lower placebo response – and, in fact, a lower depression response. They suggest that since medication resistant depressed patients are very unresponsive to any intervention at all, rTMS studies should focus on non-refractory patients. At least future rTMS trials should quantify the degree of refractoriness of each patient. The placebo response is high in add-on rTMS trials – this could indicate there is a synergistic effect with the drug and, therefore, future trials could use a two-way factorial design (i.e., sham vs. real-rTMS and placebo vs. active drug) to address the relationship among rTMS and drug interventions.

ResearchBlogging.org
Brunoni, A., Lopes, M., Kaptchuk, T., & Fregni, F. (2009). Placebo Response of Non-Pharmacological and Pharmacological Trials in Major Depression: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis PLoS ONE, 4 (3) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0004824

 

6 Responses to “The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation”

  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am
  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am
  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am
  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am
  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am
  1. The placebo response is rather well documented in most pharmacotherapeutical studies. Also psychotherapeutic interventions such as CBT (difficult to blind test) and procedural interventions (tDCS, rTMS but also ECT) cannot be expected to be without at least a 25-30% placebo effect).
    What is known on placebo studies in ECT ?

    Dr. G. Otte

  2. Otte Georges on June 4th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
  3. [...] Shock, The Placebo Response of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation But the magnets are so big! Some good considerations of the placebo effect and approaches to new [...]

  4. Wednesday Round Up #72 « Neuroanthropology on July 15th, 2009 at 4:11 pm
  5. [...] The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation The field of placebo response with the use of… [...]

  6. Science Report » Blog Archive » The Placebo Effect Explained in a video on February 22nd, 2010 at 7:53 am
  7. [...] been a while since my last post on this blog about transcranial magnetic stimulation [...]

  8. TMS for medication resistant depression | Dr Shock MD PhD on May 4th, 2010 at 8:29 am
  9. The placebo response of transcranial magnetic stimulation | Dr Shock MD PhD adam@comemail.net

  10. Jorn on June 28th, 2010 at 12:10 pm
  11. Very helpful article and a great site. Been looking for good informational websites like mine with relevant info to share with others and this is definitely going to be one of them! Thanks!

  12. Lynn Masterson on July 18th, 2010 at 1:28 am

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: